Beiträge von Vouk

Fixed in the next version.

Yes, it should be slightly faster because premiere is not involved rendering the frame. But if it is almost the same then it is okay.

About aac vs. mp3... did you try to export video only? What about that?

Seems there is an error in building the Z-Lib in an release build.

Make Adobe reply to my question in their forum: https://forums.adobe.com/thread/2627793

Digeridoo Great. Thanks for the sketches. Basically this is what I had in my mind already, yes.

1. The selection of the "Format" depends on the selection done in "Video" and "Audio". I am still trying to find out if there is a more clever way of displaying this workflow / dependency.

2. I like your idea of separating the encoding option groups in tabs. This is what I meant with "2nd level navigation". But there would still be some scrolling. Although - It would be less scrolling than it currently is. But i guess we can't get araound it with like 200 options for i.e x265.

3. Advanced - Yes, maybe not at this position but I want to have it in this view somewhere. Maybe below the options preview? I also think about not only to remove the advanced tabs in simple mode, but showing a custom simple tab instead. i.e. just showing a "Quality" slider for x264 that matches to the crf param. But thats just a detail.

4. 3D & Filters - It would be possible to put these tabs here. BUT - It could be confusing as these are not encoder options, plus they are encoder independend. They will not be affected when the encoder gets changed and they won't get cleared or resetted when the encoder options does.

Both "3D/Spherical" and "Filters" will be not used by the majority of the users. So I still think it could be reasonable to add buttons that open a new dialog. Not sure about it though.

5. Presets - We need to put a list / dropdown of encoder presets somewhere (i.e. "YouTube", "Archive", "Lossless", "Draft" or something). But this can be thought through later.

Support for QSV is already built in.

We just need to write the configuration files.

Version 2.2-beta1 -- NOT FOR PRODUCTION USE

Fixes:

• Fixed AfterEffects installer path
• Window sizes should be okay in HiDPI mode now
• AudioRenderer is only created when needed
• Hopefully fixed assertion error about wxLocale
• (libx264) Fixed 10 bit high profile selection
• (prores) Fixed pixelformat selection

Changes:

• Renamed h264 and hevc encoders so they look nicer
• Added ZScale, BWDIF, YADIF and Unsharpen filter
• (libx265) Added 'ref'option
• (h264,hevc) Added raw muxers

Download: https://github.com/Vouk/voukoder/releases/tag/2.2-beta1

Don't forget there are both audio and video filters!

And if there is alread an audio and video sidebar item... shouldn't everything video and audio related be included there? It would be also confusing to add a filter item and then have a video and audio tab in there.

Just to think about.

I will release a beta1 of the new version this afternoon, so you get an impression of the current situation.

Still, I prefer us to think about the general structure and not about a single component (like the filters). How can we put all components in there in a nice way and how to navigate between them?

As a first step i followed Digeridoo s suggestion and removed all tabs and integrated them in the sidebar.:

Whats still missing is to separate the "General" tab into "Video", "Audio" and "Muxer/Format" sidebar items.

Thats where it gets complicated:

When I click on i.e. "Video" in the sidebar I need to have a way to display the ...

• Encoder options (per encoder) - each group in a different tab/panel
• Side data
• Filter List
• Presets

This would require at least some kind of second level navigation for the options.

Any ideas / suggestions?

As far as I remember lossless can be set with setting a constant quantizer value of 4.

But 10bit support is new to me. Everything in voukoder is like YUV 4:2:0 8 bit.

Also see: https://developer.nvidia.com/video-encode-d…-support-matrix

Just check if FFmpeg is significantly faster than voukoder for the same video file.

This is also probably fixed in the next version. Please retest once it is available.

This happened when trying to load the PNG icons. I guess I fixed it in the next version. We'll see.

Das ist jetzt auch behoben.

Raw streams für h264 and hevc sind jetzt drin.

Ich schau mal ob ich schon ne beta rausgeben kann.

Es reicht intern die Daten im entsprechenden pixelformat yuva444p10 anzuliefern, daran erkennt er es schon.

Ja, interner Farbraum. Voukoder muss ein entsprechendes Pixelformat anfordern und bekommt die Daten dann in diesem Format. Leider sind diese Formate nicht identisch mit denen in FFmpeg/libav so das u.U. noch eine Konvertierung erfolgen muss.

YUV420 (planar) geht direkt durch

YUV422 und YUV444 müssen von packed nach planar umgewandelt werden

Alles mit mehr als 8 bit wird als YUVA4444 32 bit float geholt und aufwändig nach yuva444416p konvertiert und dann nochmalsvon FFmpeg/libav ins entsprechende Zielformat gewandelt. Deswegen sind 10 und 12 Bit auch relativ langsam.

morphinapg There were some issues with the required .NET framework. I was not able to install it under win 10.

I did some scribbles recently and i think it is a good idea to separate this in two parts (at least):

1. How to navigate within Voukoder?

• Sidebar vs. tabs?
• How display 3 layers of navigation (i.e. Video > Encoder > Options)?

2. How to configure options like encoders, filters, side data?

• Property grid vs. standard controls vs. custom controls (what should each cutsom control look like?)
• How to display layers of options (i.e. one option will only appear if a different options has a specific value selected)
• How to display a simple view with limited option set and an advanced view with all options

Basically I agree to everything Digeridoo mentioned above.

(tbc)

Die Sache mit der Skalierung ist in der nächsten Version behoben. (Siehe Incorrect window size on High DPI screen )

Es macht meines Erachtens keinen Sinn einfach alle Formate/Muxer einzubinden.

1. Wäre das einfach zu viel Arbeit

2. Sind da exotische / historische Formate darauf die absolut nicht mehr relevant sind

bzgl. TS und M2TS: Diese sind meines Wissens nach für MPEG2 relevant was noch nicht angebunden ist, kann ich aber machen.

Für andere Formate + Enkoder bitte gezielt diejenigen nennen die vermisst werden.